Good Reasons for Being an Agnostic Watch: A Fifth Force of Nature? Things Just Got More Interesting

A “bump” in the data generated at Fermilab has the physics world buzzing. The following is in the New York Times today:

“Nobody knows what this is,” said Christopher Hill, a theorist at Fermilab who was not part of the team. “If it is real, it would be the most significant discovery in physics in half a century.”

There are four possibilities. Physicists have discovered: 

  • a new force of nature (!);
  • the Higgs Boson;
  • something not understood about regular physics; or
  • a statistical anomaly.

Of these, according to the New York Times, one Fermilab physicist pretty much rules out the possibility that the Higgs particle has been discovered:

This could not be the Standard Model Higgs, Dr. Punzi and his colleagues concluded, because the Higgs is predicted to decay into much heavier particles, namely quarks. Moreover, the rate at which these mystery particles were being produced was 300 times greater than Higgs bosons would be produced.

If real, it was something totally new, Dr. Punzi said. The result had recently been strengthened, he said, by new calculations of interactions between quarks, which are notoriously difficult to compute. “It is so new, so astonishing, we ourselves can barely believe it,” he said. “We decided we had to let the whole world know.”

How about an anomaly? How likely is that? Not high, but certainly possible:

The experimenters estimate that there is a less than a quarter of 1 percent chance their bump is a statistical fluctuation, making it what physicists call a three-sigma result, enough to attract attention but not enough to claim an actual discovery. Three-sigma bumps, as every physicist knows, can come and go.

So it’s perhaps 1 chance in 400 that the findings are an anomaly. The physicists will need to do more searching. But that leaves us with two intriguing (even likely) possibilities:

  • a new force of nature has been found; or
  • something not understood about regular physics has been stumbled upon.

In either case, the discovery could upend our conceptual (and, conceivably, our technological and spiritual) lives.

We don’t really know who we are, where we are, or what we are, do we?

These are good times for being an agnostic.

About Santi Tafarella

I teach writing and literature at Antelope Valley College in California.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

3 Responses to Good Reasons for Being an Agnostic Watch: A Fifth Force of Nature? Things Just Got More Interesting

  1. Colin Hutton says:

    Top of my wish list : a discovery that provides evidence for the existence of free will.


    • santitafarella says:


      Wouldn’t that evidence be the next time you decide to, say, pick up a pencil off of a desk?

      If I say—“The pencil rose into the air because I decided that it would (and I might just as well have decided for it not to)”—what evidence is there that I’m deluded about this?

      So I would turn your question on its head: what discovery provides evidence against the existence of free will (something that, in my experience, appears quite obvious to me)?


  2. “Let us turn for a moment, Venerable Brethren, to that most disastrous doctrine of agnosticism. By it every avenue to God on the side of the intellect is barred to man, while a better way is supposed to be opened from the side of a certain sense of the soul and action.”

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s