A Good Reason to Stop Fearing Cancer

If you worry about detecting cancer early, and therefore anxiously get regular cancer screenings, the New York Times today has an article on cancer screening that puts the whole subject into perspective: early detection doesn’t reduce the actual mortality rates from most cancers all that much. To my mind, this is the money quote:

[D]octors and patients are stuck in a sort of cancer time warp. The disease was defined in 1845 by a German doctor, Rudolf Virchow, who looked at tumors taken at autopsy and said cancer is an uncontrolled growth that spreads and kills. But, of course, he was looking only at cancers that killed. He never saw the others.

“Now we are backing away from that,” Dr. Brawley said. In recent years, researchers have found that many, if not most, cancers are indolent. They grow very slowly or stop growing altogether. Some even regress and do not need to be treated — they are harmless.

“We are going from an 1845 definition of cancer to a 21st-century definition of cancer,” Dr. Brawley said.

I’m not offering the above quote to suggest that you shouldn’t bother with cancer screenings. Do what your doctor recommends for you. But the article is interesting, and perhaps a bit comforting to hypochondriacs. If an especially lethal form of cancer comes your way some day, you’re probably not going to keep that particular truck of death from barreling over you by noticing its approach early. So, if you’re worrying about whether you’ve got cancer, let me tell you what you’ve really got. Today. Carpe diem.


About Santi Tafarella

I teach writing and literature at Antelope Valley College in California.
This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

1 Response to A Good Reason to Stop Fearing Cancer

  1. Number Six says:

    I still think Wilhelm Reich had some very perceptive and possibly even insightful things to say about cancer…How it was a result of a kind of closing in on oneself; a darkening of body, but also mind and soul. You can see that as New Age claptrap or, as the FDA saw it, as a medical scam of the highest order (which required punishment and even eventually imprisonment), but there’s a wisdom beyond all the wild theorizing of orgone energies and all that jazz. When life gets tamped down, warped, or otherwise constrained, it mutates and becomes pathological (and here I think of Canguilhem and the vexing nature of “normal” and “pathological”). One of those pathologies is cancer. You can talk about it in terms of cells and their dis-function. But maybe sometimes that’s just too narrow, reductionist and disconnected an understanding of dis-function…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s